The pronunciations of STRUT. Six informants spread over most of the county had the new
[a]-like pronunciation, while two in East Kent still had the older [ʌ]-like pronunciation.
The map shows that the new [a]-like pronunciation dominated most of Kent, with a small area in East Kent still acquiring the older [ʌ]-like pronunciation. Six informants had acquired the [a]-like pronunciation by 1865-1895, the Table suggesting that perhaps 25% of the county still retained the old pronunciation. This means that the origin of this change is probably a little later than PRICE and GOAT, starting perhaps around 1810-1820.
This post continues from the introductory Nineteenth century sound change in Kent, where the informants are introduced and the background presented.
The numbers of informants with new pronunciations (N) and old pronunciations (O), for each of the ten sound changes, ordered from the left by the total number of O acquired, assuming a progression from the earliest to the most recent. The grand total for each sound change is 8, the number of informants. The new [a]-like STRUT was acquired by six out of the eight informants, and the earlier [ʌ]-like pronunciation by two.
Alexander Ellis (1889, On Early English Pronunciation, Vol. 5, Teubner) recorded the surviving dialect pronunciation of STRUT in Kent and East Sussex as [ʌ]. His examples were collected in the 1870s from adults whose speech was acquired in the 1850s or earlier. Henry Sweet (1877, Handbook of Phonetics, Oxford, Clarendon), gave [ʌ] as the corresponding RP pronunciation.
F1/F2 diagrams for STRUT in 19th century Kent
Cardinal [ʌ] is produced like cardinal [ɔ], but without rounded lips, which will mean higher F1 and F2 than for [ɔ]. The two informants with the old [ʌ]-like STRUT have F1 around 500-600Hz and F2 1000-1200Hz, (f and h above). The other informants, right across Kent, all have the new [a]-like STRUT, with F1 above about 600Hz, and, typically have F1 extending as high as 700 or 800Hz.
The earlier [ʌ]-like STRUT
up, other, one, money, mother, bundle
fun, tub, coupl'(h)im up, bunyon, one
The new [a]-like STRUT
come, bungalow, done
- Goudhurst 1881:
lunch, dozen, one, summertime, cut
run, much, up, trouble
- Bromley1866 (H. G. Wells):
Russia, summing, does, structure, construct
cut, front, up, trouble
cut it up, oven, (h)undredweight, runnin(g), fuss
Examples from contemporary RP
For comparison, here are two RP examples, contemporaries of the Kentish informants. One is a political broadcast recorded by the BBC in 1931 by politician Stanley Baldwin (1867-1947), and the other is a Linguaphone recording (British Library) made in 1929 by Professor Daniel Jones (1881-1967).
F1/F2 diagram, showing the [a]-like RP STRUT
Both Baldwin and Jones have the new [a]-like STRUT, with F1 600-800Hz, despite Daniel Jones’ describing the older [ʌ]-like form (like Ellis and Sweet), unmodified through all nine editions of Outline of English Phonetics. At some time, possibly the amended 8th or 9th editions (1956 and 1960), he added a new §335a, describing a variant approaching cardinal a in what he called Southern English, “a less ə-like vowel than mine”. However, his instances of STRUT in the recording below are definitely not ə-like.
- Stanley Baldwin:
country, government, courage, trust, suffering
- Daniel Jones:
up, luggage, tugs, under, luggage
This is one more RP puzzle, [a], not [ʌ], for STRUT by RP speakers born in the 19th century and recorded around 1930. And then, in the 1950s, Daniel Jones described an [a]-like STRUT as regional. Gimson (1962, An Introduction to the Pronunciation of English, Arnold) described STRUT as a “centralized and slightly raised cardinal [a]” in “general RP as used by younger people”. This means that the [a]-like STRUT has been recognized in RP roughly since the post-1945 period. This is confirmed by Fabricius’ longitudinal study back to 1900 (2007, Variation and change in the trap and strut vowels of RP: a real time comparison of five acoustic data sets, Journal of the International Phonetic Association 37:293-320). Harrington, Palethorpe and Watson (2000, Monophthongal vowel changes in Received Pronunciation: an acoustic analysis of the Queen’s Christmas broadcasts, Journal of the International Phonetic Association 30:63-78) also reported the [a]-like STRUT in the speech of the Queen (born in 1926), with F1 600-1000Hz. So who had the [ʌ]-like STRUT? Alexander Ellis, born in 1814? Henry Sweet, born in 1845? But Stanley Baldwin and Daniel Jones demonstrate that this sound change was appearing in RP already in the late 19th century, about the same period that it was spreading through rural Kent.
©Sidney Wood and SWPhonetics, 1994-2016